Which 1989 McFarlane cards are these?
The set is Comic Images’ 1989 Todd McFarlane Series 1, also cataloged as Spider-Man McFarlane I and Todd McFarlane Super Heroes — Series 1. Match the publisher, year, artwork, title, and card number before comparing listings. A shared character name is not enough to identify a card.
There are 45 numbered cards, including #45 Checklist, plus an unnumbered header. SpiderFan documents the header separately, while Trading Card Database counts 46 cards in total. Those descriptions agree once the header is accounted for. A seller’s “complete set” may refer to the numbered run, so ask explicitly whether the header is included. See the checklist sources.
A useful completeness check
Look for #1 Friends, #3 Venom, #4 Snikt, #36 Wolverine, #45 Checklist, and the separate header, then check every number in between. Do not substitute a second copy of one card for a missing number.
How to compare prices without mixing different products
A discussion in r/MarvelCards raised the gap between high complete-set asking prices and reported lower sales. It is a useful question, but a Reddit anecdote is not a verified market comp. This guide does not establish a current complete-set price.
- Compare like contents. A complete numbered set, a set with the header, one Venom card, a mixed lot, and an unopened pack are different products. Inspect photographs and the item description as well as the title.
- Separate asking prices from completed sales. Active asks show available supply and seller expectations. For sale evidence, record the sale date and confirm that the listing actually matches. If an accepted-offer price is hidden, do not assume the crossed-out asking price was paid.
- Match condition and grading. Keep raw cards separate from graded cards. For slabs, match the grading company and grade. For raw copies, compare corners, edges, surface, and centering; a seller’s prediction of a future grade is not a graded result.
- Use a consistent total. Record the currency and shipping cost. Keep a price including shipping separate from a card-only price, and remember that taxes or import charges can change the buyer’s total.
- Read beyond a single sale. Check dates, seller feedback, exact contents, and more than one comparable transaction when available. Sparse or unmatched evidence should remain uncertain rather than becoming a precise value.
Why adding up singles does not prove a set price
A buyer completing one missing card and a buyer purchasing a whole set are making different purchases. Adding individual prices can also add shipping costs many times. Any sum of singles needs to be labeled as that calculation; it is not an observed sale of a complete set.
CollectAIO’s catalog work for this guide covers the English singles and header with Raw variations. It does not establish a complete-set valuation. Some cards may have limited evidence or no price. On item pages, read the evidence dates and confidence labels, and keep active asking-price summaries separate from completed-sale evidence.
1989 Todd McFarlane Series 1 checklist
The numbered run is listed below, followed by the header. Card links open the matching CollectAIO catalog page; they do not imply that every card has a current supported market price. Titles follow our catalog, with punctuation varying slightly across checklist references.
| Number | Card title and catalog page |
|---|---|
| 1 | Friends |
| 2 | Jump for Joy |
| 3 | Venom |
| 4 | Snikt |
| 5 | Oh, Yeah |
| 6 | Savage |
| 7 | The Leader |
| 8 | Spidey |
| 9 | X-Factor |
| 10 | Price of Fame |
| 11 | Chance |
| 12 | Thing |
| 13 | The Prowler |
| 14 | Don't Cry |
| 15 | Lizard |
| 16 | Who, Me? |
| 17 | Taskmaster |
| 18 | Busted |
| 19 | Silver Sable |
| 20 | Sandman |
| 21 | Out of the Fire |
| 22 | Green Goblin |
| 23 | Hobgoblin |
| 24 | The Black Fox |
| 25 | There's No Key?! |
| 26 | Ho Ho Ho |
| 27 | Hey, Tiger |
| 28 | Aargh |
| 29 | The Chameleon |
| 30 | Killer Shrike |
| 31 | Peter |
| 32 | Mary Jane |
| 33 | Jolly Jonah |
| 34 | Styx & Stone |
| 35 | Smile |
| 36 | Wolverine |
| 37 | Mysterio |
| 38 | Down and Out |
| 39 | Humbug |
| 40 | Black Cat |
| 41 | Next |
| 42 | Hydro-Man |
| 43 | Buddies |
| 44 | Web Swinging |
| 45 | Checklist |
| NNO | Header Card (unnumbered) |
Common questions
How many cards are in the 1989 Todd McFarlane set?
Series 1 has 45 numbered cards, including #45 Checklist, plus an unnumbered header card. That is 46 distinct cards when the header is included. Ask whether a complete-set listing includes the header.
Is a high eBay asking price proof of what the set is worth?
No. An active listing records what a seller is asking. Compare completed sales for the same complete set, condition, contents, currency, and shipping basis before drawing a value conclusion.
Can I add individual card prices to value a complete set?
Adding singles prices gives a singles-based estimate, not an observed complete-set sale. Complete sets and individual cards are different transactions, with different demand, shipping costs, and selling effort.
Does CollectAIO have these cards?
CollectAIO has catalog pages for the 45 numbered English Series 1 singles and the unnumbered header with Raw variations. A catalog entry does not guarantee a current price or sufficient completed-sale evidence.
Sources and scope
Checklist references reviewed October 15, 2026. These independent collector references support identity and contents, not a current price. No new marketplace refresh was performed for this article.
- SpiderFan: 1989 Comic Images Spider-Man McFarlane I
- Trading Card Database: 1989 Todd McFarlane checklist
- Jeff Allender’s House of Checklists: Todd McFarlane Series 1
CollectAIO publishes this guide and operates the linked catalog. Marvel and the other named rights holders are not represented as endorsing this guide.